Challenges TO Secularism IN India PDF

Preview

Summary

India is well-known for its cultural diversity, particularly in terms of language and religion. Hindus make up the majority of the population, while Muslims make up the largest minority. The British rulers were largely responsible for the animosity between Hindus and Muslims. To maintain their power...

Description

CHALLENGES TO SECULARISM IN INDIA

India is well-known for its cultural diversity, particularly in terms of language and religion. Hindus make up the majority of the population, while Muslims make up the largest minority. The British rulers were largely responsible for the animosity between Hindus and Muslims. To maintain their power, they adopted a 'divide and rule' strategy, attempting to foster feelings of hostility between the members of these two communities. Following a long history of independence, the lack of proper adjustment between them has frequently resulted in violent outbursts and communal riots, posing a serious threat to our country's secular identity. Political parties, including national parties, on the other hand, do not always allow secularism to take precedence over their political interests. Tradition guides the electorate in India, which responds to appeals based on caste, religion, and language. Political parties openly violate the idea of secularism they claim to stand for by announcing various schemes favoring a particular community. Nearly all political parties consider a candidate's religion when distributing tickets during elections. In India, this practice poses the greatest threat to secularism.

The Problem of a Uniform Civil Code: A uniform civil code is critical for achieving national identity and bringing members of all religious communities together in a single bond of common citizenship. It was hoped that after independence, this step would be taken to usher in a secular society. However, no progress has been made in the development of a uniform Civil Code, and its adoption now appears to be more difficult than it was when the Constitution was drafted. As a result, the Muslim minority forced the government to enact legislation concerning divorced women's maintenance in 1986, which it believed was closer to its Personal Law and thus more religiously acceptable. The Government paid no attention to modern secular considerations or the views of Muslims who took a secular stance. Similarly, other minorities, such as Christians and Sikhs, have made statements that make the formulation and enforcement of a uniform Civil Code impossible. Such limitations indicate that India's path to a truly secular society is littered with stumbling blocks. Politics and Religion: In India, political parties have a history of using religion and caste factors to advance their political agendas, severely undermining secular values. In India, the rise of communalism has hampered the development of genuine secularism. Despite the abandonment of communal electorates and the prohibition on using religion to solicit votes, political parties and groups have frequently used communal factors to gain power. Both minorities and majority communities are

equally responsible in this regard. Secularism will not be able to take root in Indian soil unless this sense of communalism is suppressed. The responsibility for undermining India's limited secularism falls on the shoulders of post-Nehru leaders, many of whom are not intellectually liberated enough to understand and appreciate genuine secularism due to their traditional backgrounds. These leaders lack true commitment to the secularisation of Indian society, not only in terms of developing a non-religious outlook, but also in terms of developing a rational and scientific temper, due to their neo-traditional orientation. This leadership failure has thwarted India's progressive separation of religion and politics. Failure of the Government to Create a Just Economic Order: The government's failure to create a just economic order and eradicate poverty was also a major setback for secularism. The masses, who were suffering from deprivation and grinding poverty, were unable to develop faith in a polity that failed to provide them with basic necessities, and thus did not place a high value on secular values.

Minority Group Perceptions: Prejudice and discrimination are seen as operating in the area of intergroup violence and conflict, in addition to education and jobs. There is now ample evidence to show that during communal riots, the state's administrative machinery does not always operate impartially; those in charge of maintaining law and order act in a non-secular manner and tend to victimise members of minority groups. Minorities are afraid of the vast majority, which has the power to overpower them and rob them of their distinguishing characteristics. Furthermore, rather than being universal, loyalties remain particularistic. Defective Educational System: In addition to encouraging people to think in terms of groups and communities, the flawed educational system has failed to instil secular ideas in the minds of young students and promote a sense of mutual give and take. Distortion of Constitutional and Democratic Institutions: The weakening of India's secularism has been exacerbated by the distortion of constitutional and democratic institutions. The Constitution and political institutions have not functioned as the framers of the Constitution intended. Although it is illegal to use religion to solicit votes, certain political parties have made extensive use of religious, caste, and other factors to secure votes. All of this has hampered the country's development of a true secular polity.

SECULARISM IN CONTEMPORARY INDIA Despite the fact that secularism is one of the fundamental elements of our

Constitution's basic structure, religious feelings not only govern our way of thinking, but also manifest themselves in our politics and public administration, participation in religious functions, and the solicitation of votes in the name of religion. Religion is used by all political parties to gain power. Vote banks are systematically built on the basis of religion and caste, despite professing secularism. Every political party claims to be India's only secular party, claiming that it takes better care of minorities than the others. To make their point, such parties try to apply different laws to different people, resulting in a crisis in which groups isolate themselves and cause dissatisfaction among others. This is clearly a hopeless situation. A scenario like this would be ripe for disintegration. What's needed is a unified system that everyone can agree on in order to effectively control and rule over a large group of people. There must be a legal system that is impartial and fair to all segments of the population. In India, a secular state, as defined by the Constitution, was not solely a politicalintellectual construct, but also reflected the social and cultural realities of the country. Because they were aware of the social reality, Mahatma Gandhi and Nehru placed a high value on communal harmony in order for India's secularism to survive. Tolerance must be a common principle for secularism to survive, and this necessitates a secular polity. Politics is the process of using government to solve people's problems. People's problems with food, comfort, and security can be easily solved under a properly functioning secular government. However, interfering with a government's functions based on religious beliefs and spiritual considerations defeats the purpose.

CONCLUSION Secularism is more than a word; it is an idea that was espoused by India's founding fathers and the architects of its Constitution. It refers to a set of principles and values that govern how a plural society and its state should be structured. The basic concept is that the state and its laws should not interfere with religious matters. Instead, each religion should provide a solid foundation for the government's secular efforts to transform Indians into good citizens. For India, secularism is more than a point of view; it is a matter of survival; it is a safeguard for the country's peace, order, and sanity. In India, secularism entails the state treating all religions equally. The Indian Constitution contains a number of provisions aimed at upholding the secular tradition. Gandhiji believed that religion was solely a matter of personal choice. He was against state aid to religious institutions, either in part or entirely. He was

opposed to denominational and sectarian religious teachings being instilled in state institutions. He wanted religious education to be solely the responsibility of religious organisations. Gandhiji believed that all religions must be able to understand and tolerate one another. According to Nehru, secularism was not only a political doctrine, but also a social one with revolutionary implications, encompassing all religions and communities in India. Religious freedom, state neutrality in religious matters, secularism in social life, and secularism as a mental attitude are all aspects of Nehru's views on secularism. In India, there are some challenges to secularism, such as the lack of a uniform civil code, religious politicisation, the government's failure to develop a just economic order, minority group perceptions, a flawed educational system, and the distortion of constitutional and democratic institutions....