Criminal law inchoate offences PDF

Preview

Summary

Lecture 9...

Description

What are inchoate offences? - inchoate literally translated means 'at an early stage' - they are crimes where defendant has not actually committed a substantive offence but has taken steps towards committing it - they amount to criminal offences in themselves.

When will an inchoate offence be committed? - when defendant attempts to commit an offence - when defendant enters into a conspiracy with at least one other person to commit an offence - when defendant assists or encourages someone else to commit a crime

What is an attempt? - An attempt to commit a criminal offence is some conduct by the defendant with the aim of committing a criminal offence which, for some reason, does not succeed or is abandoned. - e.g. defendant shoots at victim intending to kill him but the bullet misses. This is attempted murder.

Section 1(1) of the Criminal Attempts Act 1981 - states that an offence of attempt is committed if: 'with intent to commit an offence... a person does an act which is more than merely preparatory to the commission of the offence..'

Actus Reus ; - defendant does an act - which is more than merely preparatory to the commission of the offence (only applies to triable wither way or indictable offences)

D does an act - there is no liability for attempt of a summary offence unless parliament creates a specific statutory provision stating that there should be - for the offence of drink driving - for example, the RTA 1998 provides that it is an offence to drive or attempt to drive after drinking more than the prescribed limit. - Cases ; Mason v DPP 2009, Moore v DPP 2010 - It is possible for an act done in another country to amount to an attempt to commit a crime in England. In DPP v Stonehouse 1978 - the D was convicted of attempting to enable his wife to obtain property by deception.

More than merely preparatory - this is a matter of degree and section 4(3) requires the judge to find some evidence that meets the standard. - Boyle and Boyle 1987, Tosti 1997, Jones 1990, Litholetovs 2002, AG's Ref 1993, Toothill 1998 - Cases must be decided on an individual basis with reference to past judgments. - Examples where the D's conduct was not more than merely preparatory - Widdowson 1986, R v Bowles 2004, Gullefer 1990, Campbell 1991, Geddes 1996

Mens Rea; - The Mens Rea of an attempt is D's intention to commit an offence. - Attempt is a crime of specific intent and recklessness will not suffice. - It must be shown that D intended to commit the result. It may be that the substantive offence can be committed recklessly, but D will not be guilty of an attempt to commit that offence if intention cannot be proved. - Millard and Vernon 1987, Pace and Rodgers 2014. - For example, criminal damage can be committed recklessly but intention must be established if D is charged with attempted criminal damage. It will not be sufficient for the prosecution to prove that D was reckless as to whether he would destroy or damage property.

Murder cases- in attempted murder cases, nothing less than an intent to kill will do - Whybrow 1951 - An intention to commit GBH would constitute attempted GBH only. The mens rea can take the form of direct intention or oblique intention - Pearman 1985 In relation to attempted murder, liability will depend upon whether D's purpose was to kill, or alternatively, whether death was a virtually certain result where the D knew this.

Relevance of recklessness - The CAA 1981 simply requires an intention to commit an offence and does not distinguish between circumstances and consequences. - The rule adopted by the court is - though D must intend any consequence, it is sufficient if he is reckless as to the existence or any circumstance, if recklessness as to that circumstance is sufficient for the full offence.

Attempting the impossible; - section 1(2) and (3) If the commission of the offence is impossible, obviously no one can be convicted of actually committing it. But it does not follow That no one can be convicted of attempting to commit it. Examples of when a defendant can be guilty of an attempt to commit an offence which he expected to commit; - outside intervention or D's own incompetence - D is interrupted by the police or others or does not possess sufficient means to accomplish his aim and commit the offence - Absence of a target object - Legally impossible to commit - attempting to handle stolen goods despite no evidence that goods were in fact stolen - Houghton v Smith 1971 - Shivpuri 1986, Jones 2007...