American Dirt In Depth Summary and Analysis PDF

Preview

Summary

American Dirt In Depth Summary and Analysis...

Description

American Dirt In Depth Summary and Analysis

Overview American Dirt is a work of fiction by Jeanine Cummins published in 2020 by MacMillan Press. This guide refers to the first US edition. The controversial, cross-genre novel combines elements of a commercial thriller, literary fiction, suspense, and romance. The title refers to the land comprising the geopolitical entity that is the United States of America, and to the contempt undocumented migrants face both before and after crossing the US-Mexico border. While many critics initially praised the book for its propulsive plot and poignant treatment of an underrepresented group, others objected to its portrayal of Mexicans; characterizing the novel as stereotypical, opportunistic, and parasitical; while also accusing Cummins of cultural appropriation. A vitriolic debate centering on who can tell which stories emerged in the press and on social media, prompting the publisher to cancel Cummins’s book tour. The book is written in alternating third-person viewpoints. Its moral voice unequivocally lands on the side of migrants, while its simple language creates a sense of immediacy and conveys the terror of the migrant experience. Plot Summary Lydia Quixano Pérez, a bookstore owner in Acapulco, saves her son Luca from a massacre that wipes out their entire family at a quinceañera cookout. The perpetrators are three sicarios, killers for Los Jardineros, a violent local cartel. Javier Crespo Fuentes, Lydia’s close friend and the jefe of Los Jardineros, ordered the hit in retaliation for an exposé written by Lydia’s husband, a journalist named Sebastián Pérez Delgado. Javier’s murderous rage stems not from the article itself, but from the impact it has on his daughter, Marta, who commits suicide when she learns of her father’s true identity. Lydia and Luca spend the rest of the novel running from Javier’s men, encountering a diverse cast of migrants along the road to the US. Lydia gathers necessities from her mother’s house and takes Luca to a hotel using several buses to throw off Los Jardineros. Despite her precautions, a clerk recognizes her and informs Javier. The next morning, Lydia receives a gift from the jefe with a thinly veiled threat. She and Luca flee Acapulco by bus, stopping in Chilpancingo to avoid roadblocks before pressing on to Mexico City. From the capital, they travel by commuter train to Huehuetoca, where Luca witnesses the aftermath of a sexual assault at a migrant facility. The rapist is Lorenzo, a sicario for Los Jardineros. Fearful of Lorenzo, Lydia takes Luca to the train tracks

where they meet two beautiful adolescent sisters named Soledad and Rebeca. Luca notices Lorenzo on the train. The sicario recognizes Lydia but claims he is no longer in Los Jardineros and means her no harm. The sisters invite Lydia and Luca to travel with them. Lydia, Luca, and the sisters leave Lorenzo behind in Guadalajara and ride La Bestia, freight trains used by migrants, through dangerous Sinaloa territory. Immigration agents intercept the train and load all the migrants except Soledad and Rebeca into vans. When the sisters join the others in a warehouse hours later, it is clear they have been raped. As the only Mexican nationals in the group, Lydia and Luca meet with the commander, who demands a toll for their release. Luca refuses to leave the sisters behind, which prompts Lydia to pay their toll and leaves her penniless. The group meets Beto, a vivacious, asthmatic deportee who is flush with cash. Soledad contacts a coyote named El Chacal when they arrive in Nogales. He agrees to add Lydia, Luca, and Beto to the group crossing the border, but Lydia does not have enough money. Beto volunteers to pay the difference. The migrants face their first challenge a few hours into the trek when they spy a US Border Patrol drone. Shortly thereafter, they encounter a group of armed vigilantes on the lookout for migrants and an immigration official. Other challenges arise, including a sudden storm and a flash flood that ends the journey north for two members of the group. Lorenzo tries to rape Rebeca, prompting Soledad to shoot him. Lydia finds Lorenzo’s phone and learns he offered her and Luca to Javier in exchange for his freedom from Los Jardineros. The book reaches its climax when Lydia confronts Javier over videocall and Beto dies of an asthma attack. The remaining migrants reach a campsite run by El Chacal’s contacts who drive them to Tucson in hidden compartments in their RVs. The novel ends in Maryland, where Lydia and Luca share a house with Soledad, Rebeca, and the sisters’ relatives.

5

Chapter Summaries & Analyses Chapters 1-3 Chapter 1 Summary The book opens with the massacre of a Mexican family during a quinceañera celebration in Acapulco. Sixteen people are killed at the house belonging to Lydia’s mother, including Lydia’s husband, Sebastián and her 15-year-old niece, Yénifer. The only survivors are Lydia and her son, Luca, who narrowly misses being hit by a bullet as he uses the toilet. Lydia tackles Luca. He falls and splits his lip. The two hide behind a shower wall while gunfire rings out around them. They overhear three sicarios looking for a man and a child (Sebastián and Luca). One of the killers takes a picture of a dead boy thinking it is Luca, but it is his nine-year-old cousin, Adrián. The three men search the house. Lydia notices a drop of Luca’s blood on the bathroom floor. She leans out to wipe it up with her shirt sleeve, narrowly avoiding being seen by one of the killers. The man urinates and helps himself to the barbecued chicken cooking on the grill. After a period of silence, Lydia ducks out, leaving Luca alone in the bathroom. He recalls how his mother and grandmother bickered before the massacre. The chapter ends with Lydia calling the police.

Chapter 2 Summary Lydia returns to the bathroom to fetch Luca, who is curled up in a ball and rocking on the floor. She coaxes him out the front door to spare him from the gruesome scene in the backyard. Lydia shakes uncontrollably and Luca vomits while they sit side by side on the curb waiting for the police. Officers surround the house with crime-scene tape and begin their investigation while a senior detective questions Lydia, who breaks down in tears. Luca comforts her. The medical examiner takes Luca to sit in her truck and gives him a drink while Lydia speaks to the detective. She tells him she did not see the faces of the three shooters and that Sebastián was the target. She expresses fear that the sicarios will come back to kill her and Luca. The detective silently notes that seven of the police officers and medical staff on the scene are on

6

the cartel’s payroll. One informant has already contacted Los Jardineros to report Lydia and Luca’s survival. Lydia decides to flee her mother’s house. The detective asks if she knows who is responsible for the massacre. She tells him it is her friend, Javier, the jefe of Los Jardineros. As she retrieves Sebastián’s car keys, she notices the message the killers left on his body: “My whole family is dead because of me” (11). She removes Sebastián’s wedding band, grabs 15,000 pesos from under her mother’s mattress, packs a bag, and walks away with Luca.

Chapter 3 Summary Lydia inspects Sebastián’s car to ensure it has not been rigged before retrieving their belongings. She hands Luca Sebastián’s red Yankees cap, which he wears for the rest of the novel. Lydia takes Luca on and off buses in case they have a tail. She worries she is being watched by bus drivers, many of whom work as halcones, or lookouts, for the cartel. She takes Luca to the bank to empty her account before going to Walmart to purchase necessities, including a backpack for Luca, clothing, flashlights, canteens, and a machete with a retractable blade. Lydia checks into a beach hotel under a fake name and pays for a room in cash. Even in the safety of their room, Luca is unable to release the emotions he spent the day suppressing. He watches television while Lydia organizes their belongings. Lydia steps out on the balcony, her terror overshadowing her grief. In the meantime, the clerk sends a text to the cartel informing them of Lydia and Luca’s arrival.

Chapters 1-3 Analysis Chapter 1 drops the reader in the middle of a massacre. The sounds of gunshots, breaking glass, and screaming convey the chaos and violence of the scene as Lydia and Luca hide from the three sicarios Javier sent to kill them. Cummins’s taut prose creates a sense of immediacy, while the characters’ reactions capture the terror of the experience: “Luca does not breathe. Mami does not breathe. Their eyes are closed, their bodies motionless, even their adrenaline is suspended within the calcified will of their stillness” (3). These physiological responses continue long after the killers leave. In Chapters 2 and 3, for instance, Lydia shakes involuntarily even though it is hot outside, while Luca vomits several times. Luca describes the massacre as a bad dream, foreshadowing the nightmare that awaits them as they travel

7

north to the US. Juxtaposition is a key component of Cummins’s writing. In Chapter 1, for example, she compares the position of Sebastián’s corpse to his most active moments, notably the times he plays with Luca, thereby connecting the stillness of the dead with the vitality of the living. In Chapter 3, Cummins compares Lydia and Luca’s unremarkable outward appearance to their interior turmoil, which is as evident as “a flashing neon sign” (20). Lydia’s love of Luca is a theme that runs through the opening chapters (and through the rest of the book). She expresses her love primarily by protecting him, both physically and emotionally. Her first instinct when gunfire erupts is to tackle Luca to the ground and shove him behind a shower wall while shielding his body with hers. After the sicarios leave, Lydia leads Luca out of the house through the front door to spare him from seeing his murdered relatives. She also refuses to let Luca out of her sight during the police interview. Last, she kicks an aggressive dog away as they leave the scene of the crime. A sense of pressing danger interconnects the three chapters. Immediately after the massacre, the neighbors draw their curtains closed to avoid becoming witnesses against the cartel. Soon after the police arrive, Lydia worries that some of the officers are being paid as spies for the cartel. Before retrieving her belongings from Sebastián’s car, she inspects the vehicle in search of a booby trap. Most of Chapter 3 describes Lydia and Luca getting on and off buses to avoid being tailed. The violence of the massacre causes Lydia to recall past traumas, like her father's death from cancer and her late-term miscarriage. For Luca and other children, danger is an inescapable part of life, even before the massacre: “These kids, rich, poor, middle class, have all seen bodies in the streets. Casual murder” (3). Luca has always been aware that violence would touch him one day, but that did nothing to prepare him for its impact when it finally came.

Chapter 4 Chapter 4 Summary Chapter 4 comprises a series of flashbacks, starting with Lydia and Javier’s first encounter at Lydia’s bookstore. He gallantly holds the door open while she carries a chalkboard sign outside. She is surprised by his book selection, which includes two of the ‘secret treasures’ she scatters among the other titles in her shop. He flirts with her, but she pulls away. When he returns the following week, she is delighted to learn that he enjoyed one of her ‘secret

8

treasures’–a book whose protagonist compulsively jumps off high things. Both Javier and Lydia claim to have this condition, causing their bond to grow. Javier tells Lydia he would have proposed to her “in a different life” (28). She feels guilty because she knows she would have accepted the proposal if the circumstances had been different and she weren't married to Sebastián. Javier visits the bookshop again later in the week. Two large men loitering outside make Lydia nervous. They are Javier’s bodyguards, but Lydia is blind to that fact. Lydia’s defenses come down when Javier speaks lovingly of his wife and crudely of his mistress. The two become confidants, sharing personal information about their families, including Javier’s daughter, Marta. Javier continues to flirt, but given their close friendship, Lydia is no longer concerned. He confesses his desire to be a poet and scholar. Lydia encourages him to follow his dreams, but he dismisses the idea as wishful thinking. Nevertheless, he brings his poetry to their next meeting, moving her with his vulnerability. Violence erupts between rival cartels in Acapulco. Los Jardineros, a cartel known for committing particularly gruesome murders, wins the war. During the four months that follow, life in Acapulco resumes with some semblance of normalcy. Lydia celebrates her birthday at a restaurant. Later that night, she and Sebastián discuss the recent changes to the city, expressing hope that the tourist-oriented economy will soon recover. He tells her that the jefe of Los Jardineros, known as The Owl, wants stability. Lydia worries that Sebastián’s research into the cartels will get him killed. She rummages through his backpack and learns that her close friend, Javier, is in fact The Owl.

Chapter 4 Analysis Chapter 4 consists entirely of flashbacks focusing on Lydia, Javier, and Sebastián. As such, it provides a broader context for understanding the events of the preceding and subsequent chapters. Lydia’s close friendship with Javier makes the massacre of her family more shocking. They were not killed by a random drug lord but by someone she loved and trusted. In other words, their murder was not just business–a jefe sending a warning to a meddlesome journalist–it was also a personal betrayal. Cummins devotes the bulk of the chapter to unpacking Lydia and Javier’s complex relationship. The two share an intellectual bond. They are also drawn to one another physically, though Javier is the only one to admit as much. He flirts with Lydia shamelessly, especially in the early phases of their relationship: “But, Lydia […] my other loves

9

notwithstanding, you truly are la reina de mi alma. The queen of my soul” (30). Lydia’s discomfort and guilt about Javier’s advances are tempered by his openness about his family. The two commiserate over the loss of their fathers to cancer. They also bond over their shared experiences as parents. The theme of parental love comes to the fore when Javier discusses his 16-year-old daughter, Marta, who is studying in Barcelona. Chapter 4 sheds light on another important relationship: the marriage between Lydia and Sebastián. Unlike Javier, who reminded Lydia that “life was exciting, that there was always the possibility of something, or someone, previously undiscovered” (33), Sebastián is a loving but familiar figure. The language Lydia uses to describe their night out is telling in this regard: “It was nice to be able to go out to dinner tonight” (34). Spending time with Javier in the bookshop is exciting, while a night on the town with Sebastián is merely nice. As symbols of violence and societal breakdown, the cartels cast a dark shadow over Lydia and Sebastián’s marriage. Fear of the cartels makes Lydia resent her husband’s journalistic integrity: “It felt sanctimonious, selfish. She wanted Sebastián alive more than she wanted his strong principles. She wished he would quit, do something simpler, safer” (34). Lydia’s idle concern for Sebastián after their night out foreshadows the grave danger he later faces in the name of exposing Los Jardineros. The past presented in Chapter 4 contrasts sharply with the violence that sets the book in motion and that awaits Lydia and Luca on their journey north. When Javier confesses to Lydia that his life did not turn out the way he wanted, she reflects on her satisfaction with her own life: “With the exception of having only one child, Lydia’s life had turned out precisely as she’d always wished it might […] She was content with her choices, more than content. Lydia was happy” (30). The happiness she feels serves as a foil for the terror and sorrow she experiences during and after her family’s murder. Like many in Acapulco, Lydia turned a blind eye to cartel violence, insulating herself from reality. After her family’s murder, she no longer has the luxury of ignoring cartel violence, nor can she close her eyes to the dangers facing the migrant population.

Chapters 5-7 Chapter 5 Summary Luca wakes from a nightmare at the hotel and screams when he remembers what happened. Lydia comforts him and gives him a drink of water. She turns on the television, orders room

10

service, and goes into the bathroom. Luca follows her, not wanting to be alone. Lydia takes a shower and insists he take one, too. He refuses, traumatized by the memory of hiding in the shower during the massacre. Lydia pushes the desk she placed in front of the door out of the way when the food arrives. The hotel worker hands Lydia a padded envelope before leaving, telling her it arrived last night. She panics and brings it into the bathroom. Luca vows to take care of his mother when he notices her struggling. He suggests they head north. Lydia agrees, telling him they will go to Denver where her uncle lives. She inspects the envelope before tearing it open and discovering a copy of Love in the Time of Cholera, a book she and Javier discussed. Javier highlighted a passage containing Florentino Ariza’s declaration of love to Fermina Daza. Lydia is overcome with guilt. She reads the card Javier left for her, which blames them both for the massacre and contains a thinly veiled threat. Concerned the food is poisoned, Lydia contemplates forcing Luca to throw up. Instead, she packs their belongings and hurries him out the door.

Chapter 6 Summary Lydia and Luca cross the hotel’s manicured grounds to an adjacent hotel, where she notices members of the cartel in three SUVs. She thinks back to her first meeting with Javier and imagines demanding an explanation for the massacre, fighting him, and begging him to kill her. One look at Luca banishes her dark thoughts. She and Luca set off on foot to the bus depot, where they purchase one-way tickets to Mexico City. Lydia takes Luca to the handicapped stall in the women’s bathroom to finish dressing. They talk about Colorado. A geography prodigy with an innate sense of where he is on the planet, Luca knows the state is almost 2,000 miles away by car. Lydia recalls how Luca used to impress foreign visitors to her shop with trivia about their hometowns. A woman enters the bathroom, frightening Lydia and Luca. They make their way to the lobby, where they see a story about the massacre on the news. They board the bus without incident. Filled with gratitude and relief, Luca falls asleep.

Chapter 7 Summary Although Lydia recognizes that getting out of Acapulco is a victory, she knows too much

11

about the cartels to share Luca’s optimism. She recalls travelling to and from the city when she and Sebastián were students in Mexico City. Protected by all-important tourist dollars, Acapulco remained immune to the violence affecting other parts of the country, making its fall to the cartels more shocking. The bus approaches a roadblock at Ocotito. Lydia fears it is manned by narcos or corrupt officials working for the cartels. She realizes there will be at least one roadblock between Acapulco and Mexico City run by Los Jardineros. Knowing there is a bounty on their heads, Lydia gets off the bus with Luca at Chilpancingo and tracks down Sebastián’s college roommate, Carlos. Carlos asks about Sebastián before taking Lydia and Luca to the house he shares with his devout American wife, Meredith, and their three children. Carlos proposes to take Lydia and Luca to Mexico City on a shuttle with American missionaries associated with Meredith’s former church in Indiana. Meredith objects, fearing for the safety of the missionaries. Carlos levels a direct critique at the Americans, whose work consists entirely of making pancakes and taking selfies with local chil...